Cayman First Appoints Natasha Pettier as Chief Executive Officer

Cayman First Insurance Company (“Cayman First”) has announced the appointment of Natasha Pettier as Chief Executive Officer, effective 8 May 2026. Pettier, who previously served as Vice President of Property & Casualty, steps into the role after nearly two years as a key member of Cayman First’s senior leadership team.

Since joining Cayman First in 2024, Pettier has played an important role in strengthening operational performance, digital innovation, and customer experience across the Property & Casualty business. Under her leadership, Cayman First has continued enhancing customer-facing tools such as First Online, its online portal for motor insurance customers, while also deepening customer engagement through community initiatives, sponsorships, and road safety advocacy.

Pettier brings extensive leadership experience in insurance operations, underwriting, risk management, and strategic planning, alongside a strong understanding of Cayman First’s customers, employees, brokers, and partners.

“Natasha is a trusted and respected leader whose experience, operational expertise, and deep understanding of our business make her exceptionally well-positioned to lead Cayman First,” said Alison Treco, Chairperson of Cayman First. “She has already made a meaningful impact in the company and in the experience we deliver to our clients and customers. We are confident in her leadership as we continue building on a strong foundation and delivering the high standard of service our members and partners expect.”

As Chief Executive Officer, Pettier will continue working closely with Cayman First’s senior leadership team and Board of Directors to advance the company’s strategic priorities, strengthen customer experience, and support long-term growth.

“It is a privilege to take on this role and continue serving a company that is deeply connected to the people and communities of the Cayman Islands,” said Pettier. “Cayman First has an exceptional team and a clear commitment to putting customers first. I look forward to building on that momentum by working closely with our employees, brokers, providers, and partners to continue delivering trusted protection and service for our members who rely on us every day.”

As one of the Cayman Islands’ leading insurance providers, Cayman First remains committed to delivering innovative insurance solutions while continuing to invest in technology, customer experience, and community partnerships. Learn more at www.caymanfirst.com .